Planners have second look at nursing and dementia care home plan

Planners will reconvene next week to decide whether the benefits of a large nursing and dementia care home outweigh the impact the building will have on the surrounding area.

Mujahid Afzal, of CS Manchester Road Ltd, applied to Rochdale Council to build a 74-bed nursing and dementia care home development following the demolition of Sparth House in Manchester Road, Rochdale.

The application was deferred when the planning committee met in March following concerns about the scale of the proposal and the impact on neighbours.

Sparth House is a single two-storey detached private home, with a parking area at the front and a long garden at the back.

It is bordered by of semi-detached houses to one side and two terraces on Manchester Road and on Sparthfield Avenue on the other. The rear of the property backs on to Castleton Bowling Club.

Following demolition, the proposed care home would occupy most of the plot, with main parking at the front and small outdoor spaces at the sides and back. The home would provide 21 specialist dementia care beds, 48 nursing beds, and five respite rooms.

The proposed Sparth House nursing and dementia care home in Manchester Road. Image: BCAE Architects

The council’s planning committee will consider the application when it meets on Wednesday.

Rochdale Council’s Adult Social Care department is in support of the proposals.

It said: “The Adult Social Care commissioning team is fully supportive of the proposed nursing and dementia care home development.

“This development is a strategically important addition to our local care infrastructure and aligns directly with our commissioning priorities, particularly in addressing the growing need for high-quality dementia and nursing care provision in the borough.

“This is a well-designed, community-focused development that will significantly enhance the borough’s ability to meet the needs of our ageing population. We strongly recommend that the application be approved and look forward to continuing our support as the project progresses.”

READ MORE: Ongoing drive to take knives off our streets

A planning officer’s report said: “The application was considered at the planning committee meeting on March 30. Members were advised by officers that the proposal gives rise to concerns in terms of impacts on neighbour amenity, harm to and loss of trees, and the appropriateness of the design of the building in its context.

“Despite these concerns, the proposal was recommended for approval as it was considered by officers that the benefits of the scheme in terms of provision of specialist care marginally outweighed the harms identified.

“Members declined to determine the application on this basis and decided to defer the application to allow the applicant to give further consideration to these concerns.”

The report explains that the proposed home has already been reduced in scale and any further reductions would make it financially unviable.

Recommending approval, the planning officer said: “The proposed development would provide much-needed care facilities on a previously developed brownfield site in a highly sustainable location. The proposed care home development would be beneficial in terms of meeting the borough’s needs for care provision as well as in terms of housing delivery.

 

Sparth house at 185 Manchester Road. Image: Google

“The scheme would comprise a purpose-designed care home carefully developed, with the input of the Council’s Adult Social Care staff, to meet specific care needs, which are identified as being in particular demand in the borough.

“The proposal would result in harm to residential amenity and to the appearance of the local area due to its design and the loss of attractive, prominent trees. These impacts arise mainly due to the overall scale of the development, in terms of its layout relative to neighbouring properties and within its plot, and its height and overall volume.

“The current scale of the building reflects the minimum amount of development required to support the viable operational requirements of the care home. The scheme has already been through a number of design refinements during the design process which have reduced the overall scale where possible.

“As such, the proposals now represent a balanced response to both the site constraints and the operational needs of the operator. Any further material reductions to the scale of the building would impact deliverability of the scheme.

“Cumulatively, the harms identified are substantial. Nonetheless, it is considered that the benefits of the scheme are likewise substantial, and that these marginally outweigh the harms in the planning balance. Balancing up all relevant material planning considerations, it is considered that the proposed development would represent a sustainable form of development.

“Officers therefore recommend that planning permission should be granted, subject to a number of conditions.”

SUPPORT THE ROCHDALE TIMES: FOLLOW US ON FACEBOOK

Got a story?
We’d love to hear it! Share your news with us. Email: editorial@rochdaletimes.co.uk

Share